Introduction: The Build-Up to a Breakthrough

By 2007, Rilo Kiley was on the verge of a major breakthrough. After establishing themselves in the indie music scene with their folk-infused rock sound, they were poised to join a wave of artists who would bring indie sounds into mainstream visibility. Bands like Arcade Fire, Death Cab for Cutie, and Kings of Leon were rising, and Rilo Kiley had secured their place among them with albums such as The Execution of All Things and More Adventurous.

Under the Blacklight: Exploring the Album

Released as Rilo Kiley’s fourth and final studio album, Under the Blacklight marked a departure from their previous sound. With its glossy production, incorporation of various genres, and a pronounced 70s influence, the album divided both critics and fans. Initial reviews, including one from Pitchfork, highlighted its “blinding sheen” and questioned the depth of its content, leading to discussions about the band’s perceived shift towards commercialism.

Comparative Analysis: Across Rilo Kiley’s Discography

While Under the Blacklight achieved commercial success, it is often viewed as an outlier in Rilo Kiley’s body of work. Previous albums had helped establish the band’s signature sound, primarily characterized by Jenny Lewis’s introspective lyrics and a more earnest rock approach. In contrast, the new album employed wry commentary, sexual undertones, and an exploration of L.A.’s darker aspects. This shift led some fans to question whether the band had abandoned its core sincerity in favor of broader appeal.

Legacy and Reassessment of Under the Blacklight

As Rilo Kiley prepares for a reunion, discussions from 2007 over the album’s alleged commercialization feel outdated. Following Under the Blacklight, the band went on a hiatus, during which its members focused on solo careers, further distancing the project from its indie roots. The scrutiny surrounding the album can now be viewed as a misunderstood transition rather than a blatant sellout.

Key Tracks and Musical Diversity

Musically, Under the Blacklight showcases a wide range of styles. Highlights include:

• “Silver Lining” – A standout opener featuring soft-rock elements that presents a poignant reflection on relationships.
• “The Moneymaker” – A funk-inspired track that highlights the album’s playful experimentation.
• “Dreamworld” – An example of the dreamy pop influences that permeate the album.

The album also explores tracks like “15,” reflecting ska influences, and “Dejalo,” which integrates reggaeton elements, representing the band’s willingness to experiment while maintaining a cohesive thematic narrative.

Conclusion: A Misunderstood Chapter

Ultimately, Under the Blacklight remains a complex yet charming album within Rilo Kiley’s discography. Its varied styles and themes illustrate their effort to step beyond conventions, making it an intriguing entry point for listeners unfamiliar with the band’s earlier work. While initial reactions emphasized criticisms of mainstream appeal, contemporary reflections suggest it was rather an ambitious pivot, enriching the band’s legacy.