The Controversial Case of Natalia Grace and the Barnetts
Natalia Grace’s adoption story unfolded in a way few could have anticipated, leading to a web of court disputes, criminal charges, and widespread media attention. Her experience raises critical questions about the nature of family, trust, and identity.
Background of the Adoption
In 2010, Michael and Kristine Barnett, residents of Indiana, adopted Natalia Grace from Ukraine. Initially presented as a six-year-old with a rare form of dwarfism, the Barnetts had high hopes for Natalia as they integrated her into their family, which included three biological children. Among them was Jacob Barnett, a prodigious talent in physics who began attending college at the age of 10.
The Controversy Unfolds
Just two years post-adoption, the Barnetts approached the Marion County Superior Court to request an adjustment to Natalia’s birth year, which resulted in a legal determination changing it from 2003 to 1989. This adjustment indicated that Natalia was actually 22 years old rather than the nine they believed. Following this ruling, the Barnetts moved to Canada, leaving Natalia in an apartment, which led to criminal charges for felony neglect.
The Ongoing Debate: Child or Adult?
The crux of the narrative involves the question of whether Natalia was a child who had been abandoned or an adult pretending to be a minor. Early in her adoption, the Barnetts reported several alarming incidents, including claims of behavior that suggested advanced maturity, such as menstruation and complex language skills. Michael Barnett detailed a turning point when Kristine noticed “full pubic hair” on Natalia, raising suspicions about her age.
Medical Opinions
The Barnetts sought medical evaluations that they believed confirmed their doubts regarding Natalia’s age. In a 2010 examination, Kristine asserted that a bone density scan indicated Natalia was 14—though subsequent reports suggest misinterpretations may have led to misleading conclusions.
Legal Proceedings and Public Perception
The case captured significant public attention when Natalia was left to live independently for five years after the Barnetts’ departure. In 2019, the Barnetts faced legal action for neglecting a dependent. The ensuing media frenzy sparked debates about their motives and the authenticity of their claims. Michael Barnett later acknowledged in court statements that both he and Kristine were aware that medical professionals had classified Natalia as a minor when they left her alone.
Natalia’s New Life
Following her separation from the Barnetts, Natalia was taken in by a new family, the Mans, who met her through a neighbor. Together, they asserted her identity as a child and provided support, although her relationship with the Mans later faced challenges. After a period of instability, Natalia is currently residing with the DePauls, a family who initially attempted to adopt her prior to her move to the Barnetts.
Current Status of the Parties Involved
The Barnetts pleaded not guilty to charges of neglect. Michael was acquitted, while the case against Kristine was dismissed due to insufficient evidence. In recent interviews, Natalia made allegations of mistreatment against Kristine, although no legal actions have emerged from these claims. Kristine maintains her position that Natalia was not a minor, insisting on her adult status during their time together.
Natalia’s Future
Today, at age 21, Natalia Grace is focusing on obtaining her GED and rebuilding her life after a tumultuous upbringing. Her story is being explored in the Hulu series “A Good American Family,” bringing renewed scrutiny to her complex past.
Natalia continues to share her perspective, emphasizing that the portrayal of her as an adult is untrue. While the Barnetts and Natalia’s evolving narrative raises many questions about identity and responsibility, it also highlights the intricacies involved in adoption and familial relationships.